G.O.A.T

[Mark Valis]

So me and Matt Heenan had this discussion over a few at Creegan's.
What would be your All Time starting 9 by position in baseball?

P- Bob Gibson
C-Josh Gibson
1B- Albert Pujols
SS- The OZ
2ND- Roberto Alomar
3RD- Mike Schmidt
LF- Teddy Ball Game
CF- Ken Griffey Jr.
RF- Ichiro Suzuki ( 262 hits 1 season ,9 consecutive season with over 200 hits/ both records ) oh yeah 9 consecutive gold gloves

Line 'em up!

[Bear Dunn]

P: Sandy Koufax
C: Roy Campanella
1B: Lou Gehrig
2B: Rogers Hornsby (dude hit .424 once)
3B: Chipper Jones...His name is Larry
SS: Alex Rodriguez
LF: Teddy Williams (best hitter EVER)
CF: Say Hey Willie Mays
RF: George Herman Ruth


Dammit I want Ty Cobb on the team too, so he's my UTIL player.

[Eric Kevorkian]

Nice...

P Nolan Ryan
C Joe Mauer
1B Albert Pujols
2B Roberto Alomar
SS Derek Jeter
3B Mike Schmidt
LF Ted Williams
CF Willie Mays...i'd go with Griffey had he not dealt with all the injuries.
RF Hank Aaron

[Derek Brazauskas]

P. Kofax

C. I agree with Gibson he hit balls that still havent landed>> and well over 800hmrs

1B. Lou Gehrig

2B. Hornsby

SS. Aroid

3B. Ken Caminiti

LF Williams

CF Willy Mays

RF Babe Ruth

DH edgar martinez

[Derek Brazauskas]

Nice...

P Nolan Ryan
C Joe Mauer
1B Albert Pujols
2B Roberto Alomar
SS Derek Jeter
3B Mike Schmidt
LF Ted Williams
CF Willie Mays...i'd go with Griffey had he not dealt with all the injuries.
RF Hank Aaron

I agree Kovo, Mays did hit 660hrs though..

[Bear Dunn]

CAMINITI!! Hahaha..awesome

Maybe I should have put Mo Vaughn at 1B

[Eric Kevorkian]

I think i'm one of a handful of people out there that owns a Caminiti jersey!

[Derek Brazauskas]

CAMINITI!! Hahaha..awesome

Maybe I should have put Mo Vaughn at 1B

LOL.. I figured I would get some flack for that... Had to put one of my Boys on there even though he shouldnt be there!! RIP Ken!!

I change it to Graig Nettles..

[Derek Brazauskas]

I think i'm one of a handful of people out there that owns a Caminiti jersey!

Wanna sell it?

[Eric Kevorkian]

heeeeeell no! He was one of my favorite players growing up...collected all his cards, and one day while @ building 19 I found a Caminiti jersey...$7!!!!

The thing is all tattered and faded, but I love the thing! I've had it for probably 15 years.

[Derek Brazauskas]

heeeeeell no! He was one of my favorite players growing up...collected all his cards, and one day while @ building 19 I found a Caminiti jersey...$7!!!!

The thing is all tattered and faded, but I love the thing! I've had it for probably 15 years.

nice!!

[Gary Cyr]

Interesting discussion.

Granted there are more than one selection for some of these but I just think some of your choices are so far off I've named more than one choice. I bolded mine in those instances

P – Lefty Grove –Walter -”Big Train” Johnson – Satchel Paige who did things in the negro league that were incredible long before he was allowed to play in the Majors
C – Johnny Bench – Yogi Berra
1B Lou Gehrig – Jimmie Foxx – Eddie Murray – Willie McCovey –Harmon Killebrew
SS Alex Rodriguez – Barry Larkin – Derek Jeter- Cal Ripken Jr –Robin Yount
2nd Rogers Hornsby – Jackie Robinson
3rd I like your choice, honorable mentions here George Brett – Brooks Robinson
Left –I like your choice, honorable mentions here- Stan Musial – Rickey Henderson
Center - Willy Mays NUFF SAID get your choice outta here
Right – Hank Arron - Babe Ruth (granted he pitched too) hands down Hank!!

EDIT: because I forgot to say I agreed with Teddy Ball game in Left but wanted to mention the other two

[Eric Kevorkian]

some of your choices are so far off

How can this be??? It's an opinionated question with no "right" or "wrong" answer

I like your addition of Ricky

[Derek Brazauskas]

some of your choices are so far off

How can this be??? It's an opinionated question with no "right" or "wrong" answer

I like your addition of Ricky

Leave it to Gary....

[Eric Kevorkian]

considering it's YOUR opinion...i'd say you're right on the money

EDIT: Gary deleted his comment asking me if I thought he was right or wrong with his claim that Manut Bol is the greatest center of all time because he's 7'7

[Gary Cyr]

considering it's YOUR opinion...i'd say you're right on the money

EDIT: Gary deleted his comment asking me if I thought he was right or wrong with his claim that Manut Bol is the greatest center of all time because he's 7'7

Like a pack of mosquitoes Kovo

I deleted it for a reason,..and I don't think Bol is the greatest center of all time.

Feel free to take the last word now

[Eric Kevorkian]

considering it's YOUR opinion...i'd say you're right on the money

EDIT: Gary deleted his comment asking me if I thought he was right or wrong with his claim that Manut Bol is the greatest center of all time because he's 7'7

Like a pack of mosquitoes Kovo

I deleted it for a reason,..and I don't think Bol is the greatest center of all time.

Feel free to take the last word now

So much for having a constructive conversation...


bzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

[Joe Yaskis]

1st Brian Cormier
2nd Matt Heenan
3rd Joe Yaskis
SS Nick Nason
P Mark Valis
C Luke Gawronske
Cent Baraka
Lf Tom Williams
Rf Who cares/

[Mark Valis]

1st Brian Cormier
2nd Matt Heenan
3rd Joe Yaskis
SS Nick Nason
P Mark Valis
C Luke Gawronske
Cent Baraka
Lf Tom Williams
Rf Who cares/

UNSTOPPABLE!

[Titan Bariloni]

SS. Aroid

DB your a [bleep] and that is the proof

Great call with the addition of Rickey one of the GREATEST of all time EVER.