Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Includes new disc reviews, what bag holds the most & what shoes work best.
Check out Dirty Birdie & the other dye guys here too.
Steve Solbo
I am THEY
Posts: 10464
Joined: Thu Jun 16, 2005 1:29 pm
Location: FYF!

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Steve Solbo »

Tom Fisher wrote:kev how many rounds do you and i play together yet you have never thrown my zone??? i offer for you to throw it all the time!

anyways. you know where i stand with it. I love the zone. now that it is warmer i will throw it on hole 11 ww at borderland. i would say that is pretty good d for that disc.


You can throw it on 11, but will you reach it?
TEAM BURGESS
Matt Stroika
I live here
Posts: 4580
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 8:36 am
NEFA #: 456
Location: Pulpit Rock

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Matt Stroika »

Karl Molitoris wrote:I like you thinking about 'forehand approaches'. Under utilized (in the sport) IMO. For the vast majority of people, considering there is significantly less spin put on a disc when thrown FH opposed to BH*, understand that unless the disc is VERY over stable you'll initially get some "S-curve" throwing them...which may NOT be what you want. Sooooo, I go with the most over stable one you can find that feels good (yes, "feel" is wicked important IMO regarding less-than-full-throttle throws).

Karl
* Hopefully no one argues this fact, as they'll get trounced...just live with it and accept it.


I would suggest talking to Bunce about forehand approaches. Kid flicks a Roc perfectly straight for a long ways on his approaches. I was amazed.
Karl Molitoris
I live here
Posts: 2307
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 8:09 pm

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Karl Molitoris »

I would suggest talking to Bunce about forehand approaches. Kid flicks a Roc perfectly straight for a long ways on his approaches. I was amazed.

I can talk to him about FH approaches (...Bunce is a nice guy), but what am I suppose to talk to him about? That FH approaches are 'good'? I think - due to our frequent uses of them - we'd have a VERY short argument about this topic...as we'd both agree they're good (and then we'd talk about whatever) :wink: .
Maybe I'm missing your point.

Karl
PDGA2010ADVGMDWC
Matt Stroika
I live here
Posts: 4580
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 8:36 am
NEFA #: 456
Location: Pulpit Rock

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Matt Stroika »

Not necessarily directed at you Karl. You were talking about spin and S-curves. Bunce may not even know how he does it, but he sure can throw accurate and straight approaches with his Roc. Maybe I should talk to him?
Shawn Mullen
I live here
Posts: 4409
Joined: Mon Nov 13, 2006 3:21 pm
Location: The Home of the 4X Champs

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Shawn Mullen »

He uses DX rocs and CFR Gators for those approaches.
Image
http://mullenart.wix.com/artist

TEAM WICK 4X CHAMPIONS
Karl Molitoris
I live here
Posts: 2307
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 8:09 pm

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Karl Molitoris »

Ah, we can all learn from him and a lot of other people!

Some people have an inate ability to - without even trying - place almost as much spin on their FHs as their BHs (Stokely and Witman are two that I've known...and I'm sure there are a few others), but these are rare birds. For most people, it's a 1:1.5 ratio. And this is the reason that BHs tend to be a "better choice" for tunnel shots (where you need a very straight shot for a long ways). It's all about spin = stability son (said in my best Foghorn Leghorn).

Unfortunately (for the hard workers who truly want to get to be the best but never will) a lot of it has to do with the natural ability one brings to the table. And work as hard as they can,they'll still never do what some people can do all the time.

That's sports at the highest level(s)...suckith that it may :( .

Karl
PDGA2010ADVGMDWC
Mark Valis
I live here
Posts: 1495
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 9:42 am
Nickname: Cuban
NEFA #: 1245
Location: From the Mother F'n slums of Shaolin

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Mark Valis »

I gotta agree with Solbo the San Marino Q-Sent is where it is at ! Gotta be the old mold not that new junk
Team C-DUBYA
John DeBois
I live here
Posts: 1158
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 7:28 pm
Location: @jdbooyeah
Contact:

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by John DeBois »

Mark Valis wrote:I gotta agree with Solbo the San Marino Q-Sent is where it is at ! Gotta be the old mold not that new junk

Yea the new sentinels are garbage. Same with the new firebirds.
David Hoey
I live here
Posts: 2056
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 11:09 am
NEFA #: 938
Location: Central MA

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by David Hoey »

Throwing Forehand Produces More Touque. Fact.
Throw discs, and forget about life for awhile...
David Hoey
I live here
Posts: 2056
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 11:09 am
NEFA #: 938
Location: Central MA

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by David Hoey »

John DeBois wrote:
Mark Valis wrote:I gotta agree with Solbo the San Marino Q-Sent is where it is at ! Gotta be the old mold not that new junk

Yea the new sentinels are garbage. Same with the new firebirds.


you can add the new XD's to that list as well... classic rocs got retooled at some point a while back and those were way different as well.
Throw discs, and forget about life for awhile...
Pete Nevius
discussion lifer
Posts: 436
Joined: Mon Feb 05, 2007 6:00 pm

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Pete Nevius »

Am I the only person that likes the Lat 64 Pain?
Greenleaf Garrison
discussion lifer
Posts: 310
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2011 10:56 am
NEFA #: 1484
Location: Centerville

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Greenleaf Garrison »

Pete Nevius wrote:Am I the only person that likes the Lat 64 Pain?



i was just about to say that. While not quite as overstable or fast as a whippet or drone, it is a good, reliable, overstable midrange. However, the gold color in the brown leaves sucks the big one
Cape Cod Disc Golf Club
TEAM BURGESS
Tocobaga Disc Golf Club #181
NEFA #1484
PDGA #41828
Tom Fisher
discussion lifer
Posts: 484
Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2010 3:11 pm
Nickname: tfish
Location: Bridgewater, MA

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Tom Fisher »

Steve Solbo wrote:
Tom Fisher wrote:kev how many rounds do you and i play together yet you have never thrown my zone??? i offer for you to throw it all the time!

anyways. you know where i stand with it. I love the zone. now that it is warmer i will throw it on hole 11 ww at borderland. i would say that is pretty good d for that disc.


You can throw it on 11, but will you reach it?



yup. sure can. but def could not if there is to much of a head wind.
Closer than I was...
Disc-A-Holic
B2Bombers
Ven Vardin
discussion pro
Posts: 69
Joined: Mon Aug 09, 2010 8:30 am
NEFA #: 1342
Location: Albany NY

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Ven Vardin »

For dependable left hooks I like the Gold Latitude XXX. It flies farther than the Lightning #2 Hyzer I use for shorter left hooks from RHBH. Both are indestructible, which I need as I hit a lot of trees still. I loved the Innova Whippet I had until it broke. I'll have to check out a Champion Glow Whippet someday.
Practice with purpose.
PDGA #43051, rating 792, FPA member.
Dave Hickson
I live here
Posts: 1184
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 9:11 pm
Nickname: Hickson
NEFA #: 1285
Location: Buffumville

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Dave Hickson »

I just picked up a 172 star gator x. That [bleep] is $. By far the most dependable mid range i have ever thrown. The thing is a wicked pig. Now I gotta get the star gator L for a little more D as I can only get about 250 off the tee with a anhieser flick befor it fades out.
TEAM BUFF
Jeff Wiechowski
I have no life
Posts: 8579
Joined: Mon Mar 09, 2009 1:20 pm
Nickname: "Captain Anhyzer"
NEFA #: 1112
Location: Ballston Lake, NY
Contact:

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Jeff Wiechowski »

My Whippet decided to take a break laast night........... center court spectating at Wimbleton

Image
Image
2019 Innova Ambassador
PDGA #11653 / NEFA #1112
DisCaptains4Life
Lucas Brewer
discussion pro
Posts: 52
Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2010 2:22 pm
Location: The Vineyard

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Lucas Brewer »

i have been throwing the vector for the last few months.. for me it just isent the right disc.. im not a huge fan of the grip on it and for me it just is not working but i did give it a try. i will say that it handles windy conditions very well and is consitant on not turning over.

i will be trying the drone and possible the zone and seeing which one of those i like.. i cant rely on a firebird for doing all my overstable work for shorter shots
Riverhead DGC
Mike Murphy
I have no life
Posts: 6052
Joined: Fri Feb 16, 2007 4:03 pm
Nickname: Cheef
NEFA #: 1102
Location: Marlborough, MA

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Mike Murphy »

Just lost my champ gator. Will probably get another but I'm looking for something with the same flight but a bit faster, any suggestions?
Aces or Eights!!!
Dave Hickson
I live here
Posts: 1184
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 9:11 pm
Nickname: Hickson
NEFA #: 1285
Location: Buffumville

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Dave Hickson »

Maybe the opto pain or a star gator L. I heard they stopped making the star gator L and they do not make it in champion yet.
TEAM BUFF
Dave Hickson
I live here
Posts: 1184
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 9:11 pm
Nickname: Hickson
NEFA #: 1285
Location: Buffumville

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Dave Hickson »

A little off the subject but the archon is $
TEAM BUFF
Kevin Fanning
discussion lifer
Posts: 568
Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2005 7:20 pm
NEFA #: 1445
Location: Borderland

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Kevin Fanning »

Bought a zone and love it right now. Took maybe 4 throws to break in, holds a beautiful hyzer line. Although I have to say I just played a round with a dude who makes a great case for the hornet...
Greg Aucoin
I live here
Posts: 1449
Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2007 12:13 am
Location: Southbridge, MA

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Greg Aucoin »

Word to the Zone, Kevin. Great disc for forehand approaches when you dial it in, and don't try to overthrow it. Carrying the hornet as well would seem like a great idea, it's a much faster disc that you'd use for a different range of shots.
Keith Morin
discussion lifer
Posts: 155
Joined: Sat Sep 01, 2007 11:53 pm

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Keith Morin »

The zone is a great forehand disc, I've pulled off some seemingly impossible shots with it.
Work Day July 31st! Webster Fish and Game Disc Golf Course..
Karl Molitoris
I live here
Posts: 2307
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 8:09 pm

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Karl Molitoris »

Actually a Sharpshooter # 2 is VERY overstable right out of the box. Unfortunately, the plastic is also very soft (and thus it becomes ever-increasingly more under stable as time / tree hits happens).

Karl
PDGA2010ADVGMDWC
Jaxon Sheehy
discussion lifer
Posts: 747
Joined: Sat Aug 21, 2010 3:58 pm
NEFA #: 1434
Location: salem
Contact:

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Jaxon Sheehy »

anyone ever find that the mids with that "roc" and "wasp" style rims are a little harder to be accurate with than say a "buzz" or "gator" style rim? anyone even know what i'm talking about?

sometimes i feel like maybe i'm missing out on a lot of discs because i don't like those rims... they're a little too steep...

i was so excited to get a wasp, and when i finally did i was bummed because of that rim.

thinking about going out and getting a champ gator- as my DX gator is all beat up and not as stable as it should be anymore. used to LOVE that thing.
-Jaxon Sheehy
NEFA #1434
PDGA #60264
http://dgsquared.com
Kevin Fanning
discussion lifer
Posts: 568
Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2005 7:20 pm
NEFA #: 1445
Location: Borderland

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Kevin Fanning »

Sounds like you just prefer a low profile grip. I think what it comes down to is what is most comfortable in your hand.
What kind of shots did you buy the wasp for?.... I don't think the gator and the wasp are all too similar, but I'd take that with a grain of salt because I've never thrown a gator. Can anyone elaborate on this?
Steve Solbo
I am THEY
Posts: 10464
Joined: Thu Jun 16, 2005 1:29 pm
Location: FYF!

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Steve Solbo »

Gator is smaller diameter and deeper lipped disc.
TEAM BURGESS
Charlie Holmgren
I live here
Posts: 1014
Joined: Tue Apr 25, 2006 8:52 am
Location: Warwick

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Charlie Holmgren »

Evolution Warrior.
Gateway Disc Sports | Skylands | PoBoyZ
Lucas Brewer
discussion pro
Posts: 52
Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2010 2:22 pm
Location: The Vineyard

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Lucas Brewer »

just ordered a special edition z drone off of DD gonna try it out tomorrow and see how it works and ill post the results

first impressions are it feels right in my hand but well see how it does coming out of it :D
Riverhead DGC
Jaxon Sheehy
discussion lifer
Posts: 747
Joined: Sat Aug 21, 2010 3:58 pm
NEFA #: 1434
Location: salem
Contact:

Re: Whippet, Drone, Gator... Preffered Overstable Mids?

Post by Jaxon Sheehy »

Kevin Fanning wrote:Sounds like you just prefer a low profile grip. I think what it comes down to is what is most comfortable in your hand.
What kind of shots did you buy the wasp for?.... I don't think the gator and the wasp are all too similar, but I'd take that with a grain of salt because I've never thrown a gator. Can anyone elaborate on this?


i got it for a tourney disc- and it might be a hornet... hmm, i'll have to check. i just wanted a very stable mid range. i'm not sure on the exact shot selection. mostly when there's something like water or OB right and i want to still keep that slight hyzer line and throw over it but come back in bounds. anything with less risk i'll just grab the buzzz without thinking.
-Jaxon Sheehy
NEFA #1434
PDGA #60264
http://dgsquared.com
Post Reply