choosing a backpack-style bag

Includes new disc reviews, what bag holds the most & what shoes work best.
Check out Dirty Birdie & the other dye guys here too.
Patrick Harris
discussion lifer
Posts: 609
Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2010 8:25 pm
Nickname: DeafDiscGolfer
Location: Brattleboro, VT
Contact:

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Patrick Harris »

Jeff Cooper wrote:Also to hijack this thread a little. To those who own a simian I am thinking of buying one. I cant tell how big the bag is by pictures online and have never seen one in person(maybe I have and didnt notice). Im not tall about 5'7" is this thing gonna be a tank on my back? I like the idea that it has a stool built right into the bag and as far as disc space it seems perfect. Is it durable? Will any plastic parts of the bag stick out of it down the road like the rev bags all seem to do.


I got camo Simian in July 2010 for 10 bucks!! (actually, won the raffle for it) and used for over a year now with the quadshock strap.

Plus side: Nice spaces and can store three or four discs per four "levels" in the main compartment. Both side main pockets can hold up to four or five discs. But I use one side for discs and other side for storage (food, sunglasses case, raincoat, gloves, spare towels, etc.). Putter pockets can hold up to two each but I prefer one putter each. There's another storage stash underneath the seat inside the bag that I use for emergency kit and things that needs to be kept dry from elements. The seating pad is quite comfortable.

The Simian is TSA-approved for carry-on air travels. Fits the overhead compartment on most airlines.

Negative side: I'm a thin 6'2" guy and its bit large and you can feel the PVC pipes on backside of the bag. Simian's standard straps SUCKS!! Replace it right away with any quadshock straps!! It might be awkward for you but it depends on how and where you use the straps that works for you. I set the straps to hook the upper loops on the seat and lower loops in the middle of the bag. It hangs low below my shoulder but the padded strap laid squarely on my shoulder comfortably. The top two levels' discs sometimes comes out when you lift it and swing around to your back hard (only when you leave your cover open), I had players to pick one or two up after me :oops:. Need to stand the bag upright at all times or lay only on its backside. No raincover for the putter pockets :(

HEAVY!! About 18 pounds fully loaded. Depending on what you are carry on that day. :?

So...Will I keep it for another year?
Yes, I would. Seating feature is the biggest plus. But now Innova came out with its own seating feature which might be worth looking to. But I like Simian better and easier for me to access the discs than the standard disc bag-types. Even the bag is still on my back and being long-armed, I can able to reach around and grab either side putter pockets or side pockets or any main compartment levels (anyone can do it blindfolded if they know their discs' locations in their bags).

It would be nice if... The newer and updated Simian would include lighter (or smaller) internal frame pipes, better strap features, putter pocket raincover, padded backside, waterproof rubber bottoms, and some sort of secure ways to prevent discs coming out when swinging the bag to your back or topping over to its front side spilling out all the discs from the main compartment and sometimes putter pockets too. 8-)
Tee Off and Pay ATTENTION!! :shock:
(a twisted concept from Ed's infamous quote)
NEDDG #12 / DDGA #134 / DGCR #1287 / NEFA #1748 / PDGA #42420
Jaxon Sheehy
discussion lifer
Posts: 747
Joined: Sat Aug 21, 2010 3:58 pm
NEFA #: 1434
Location: salem
Contact:

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Jaxon Sheehy »

Got my Grip-EQ Thursday- this thing is so well designed.
and for 200 bucks, which included shipping, it's not a bad price.
with traditional style bags, you're always on the hook for that extra 40 something bucks for straps-
with that mentality, this thing cost about 160

I could wax on about the design features, but i really haven't played enough with it yet- and haven't even discovered all the mini pockets and spaces yet.

the number of discs that it holds is greater than i expected
there are about 4 or 5 slide in pockets for putters and extras that aren't part of the main compartment
which brings the total number up pretty high (over 20, but i don't feel like jamming as many discs into it just to get a number)

My total wait time was less than 2 months
I put my name on the list on September 23rd
and got my bag in the mail on November 10th.
they get in about 75 bags every two weeks now- so it's a regular basis
they also respond to even the most mundane e-mail questions

Image
-Jaxon Sheehy
NEFA #1434
PDGA #60264
http://dgsquared.com
Matt Aubin
I live here
Posts: 1895
Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 5:02 pm
NEFA #: 1202

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Matt Aubin »

buuuuuumpin' this for long-term reviews, updates etc... my bag is falling apart. :cheese:
Shaun LaForce
I live here
Posts: 2017
Joined: Tue Dec 05, 2006 7:55 pm
NEFA #: 865
Location: Rapscallion DGC

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Shaun LaForce »

Mystery Ranch is the sh!t!

Designed by a reputable backpacking company
Completely waterproof(including all the zippers)
Fully adjustable yoke
Extremely comfortable
Adjustable side pockets allows for plenty of storage
A spot to hold your umbrella as well as a stool
Forget about the price tag because you will never have to purchase another bag again


My girlfriend bought the Grip bag. It is nice but very limited for storing anything and nowhere to hook up an umbrella or stool if needed.
Chris Bolton
I live here
Posts: 1494
Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 6:31 pm
Nickname: CCOW
Location: mooing in the field
Contact:

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Chris Bolton »

Shaun LaForce wrote:Mystery Ranch is the sh!t!

Designed by a reputable backpacking company
Completely waterproof(including all the zippers)
Fully adjustable yoke
Extremely comfortable
Adjustable side pockets allows for plenty of storage
A spot to hold your umbrella as well as a stool
Forget about the price tag because you will never have to purchase another bag again



i agree 100%%%

@aubin if you want to check out the mahal up close and personal i will let you look at mine at the challenge.
Matt Aubin
I live here
Posts: 1895
Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 5:02 pm
NEFA #: 1202

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Matt Aubin »

How many discs does it hold?
Chris Bolton
I live here
Posts: 1494
Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 6:31 pm
Nickname: CCOW
Location: mooing in the field
Contact:

choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Chris Bolton »

Matt Aubin wrote:How many discs does it hold?



A lot!!! I will count it up when I get home.
Chris Irvine
discussion lifer
Posts: 209
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 10:15 am
NEFA #: 1239

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Chris Irvine »

I carry like 25 w/ out using the big side pockets (which can each hold like 6 cans of tonic).


So you could probably push 40 if you want.
Team Burgess.
Jon Gordon
discussion lifer
Posts: 846
Joined: Mon Jul 20, 2009 9:13 am
Nickname: jonny g, two times
Location: In the woods

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Jon Gordon »

When I went to am worlds this year I put all my discs plus there back ups in my bag to travel out there and it had 43 in it. I would be tough to play like that but it can do it
Team Awesomesauce
Team Pure Flight
Team Righty
Tim Carter
I live here
Posts: 1283
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 1:41 pm

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Tim Carter »

Continuing the Mahal love fest: the question how many discs does it hold does not even come up, it holds so many. And with the adjustable yoke, you don't feel all that weight. On the flip side, if ya compress the side pockets you can still carry like 16-18 and then the bag looks slimmer and trimmer than a dual pack. Also options for dealing with bad weather are unmatched (waterproofing, serious zippers, overlapping seems and a way to attach your open umbrella so that it covers both you and your bag)
TEAM BUFF

STAY CLASSY
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

Pshh! The Mahal? Seen it, tryed it out, and it sucks big time, that things like an old beat up station wagon compared to the amazing grip eq bag. Have fun with that.
Team uncensored
Tim Carter
I live here
Posts: 1283
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 1:41 pm

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Tim Carter »

Station wagon? Try winnebago! You are probably right, who would want a high quality American made product designed by a company at specializes in particular high end applications of that product?

Most people would probably prefer a product whose main selling point appears to be that the guy who owns the company is friends with a couple world champs. And the pretty colors.
TEAM BUFF

STAY CLASSY
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

The fact that they actually specialize in making bags is the sad part, they couldn't come up with something better than that?? I could careless who made the bag or who is endorsing the bag either, its all about the quality, comfort , and versatility for me. The grip bag makes me feel like a damn ninja turtle when I'm wearing it, its so secure on ymy back it doesn't hardly feel like its there, you can run, jump, or even throw a disc with it on and everything is super secure and you don't feel anything being sloshed around. And holy [bleep] this bag is versatile, its nice for traveling, as a ski back pack, a bowling bag, or whatever else you can think of. Is your Mahal that versatile ? I think not, my grip bag is part of my daily life more than any other bag could ever be. Now that's bang for your buck!!
Team uncensored
Shaun LaForce
I live here
Posts: 2017
Joined: Tue Dec 05, 2006 7:55 pm
NEFA #: 865
Location: Rapscallion DGC

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Shaun LaForce »

I wonder if I could tote around a bowling ball.

No but seriously, I don't think the Mahal can do any of that stuff you just rambled off :roll:
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

I suppose if your going hiking and your bringing 2 weeks worth of food, annnd a 3 person tent and oh! You just happen to be disc golfing as well, then the Mahal should be great for you!! I'm sorry guys but that bag is a hunk of material waiting to be filled.. with disc golf materials that make it take shape. It's all good though guys I get the psychology behind it, you want to make yourselfs believe that its something great just to justify the money you spent on it. I I understand a :wink: nd I feel for you .
Team uncensored
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

Sure bring the sarcasm, I'm cool with that, I just wanted to remind you how versatile my bag is, and how impractical yours is.
Team uncensored
Shaun LaForce
I live here
Posts: 2017
Joined: Tue Dec 05, 2006 7:55 pm
NEFA #: 865
Location: Rapscallion DGC

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Shaun LaForce »

What did I spend like $70 more than you?

You definitely provide a lot of valuable selling points for your bag.

Versatile? Really?? I can accomplish all that stuff with a simple book bag if I wanted.

Rain is in the forecast, don't forget to put that silly raincoat on your bag before you head out.

Enjoy!! :D
Matt Aubin
I live here
Posts: 1895
Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 5:02 pm
NEFA #: 1202

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Matt Aubin »

gettin' hott in hrrrr :twisted:
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

Bottom line is, do you want to feel like a ninja turtle(me), or do you want to feel like a camel in east India caring back materials for his hood?(you)
Team uncensored
Tim Carter
I live here
Posts: 1283
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 1:41 pm

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Tim Carter »

Caring camels from east india??? WTF?

It was easier to tear apart your "arguments" when they were at least coherent.
TEAM BUFF

STAY CLASSY
Eric Kevorkian
I have no life
Posts: 5107
Joined: Mon Feb 04, 2008 8:11 pm
Nickname: Kovo
NEFA #: 1304
Location: Millis, MA

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Eric Kevorkian »

Isaac, step away from the keyboard! :lol:
Team Lefty - GOATS!
John Tserpes
discussion lifer
Posts: 340
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2006 10:37 am

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by John Tserpes »

Ninja turtles can't cross the desert like a camel.
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

Wow my phone spelled caring instead of carrying , big deal. instead of scrutinizing me, how about you give me 1 reason why the Mahal is better than the grip.
Team uncensored
John Tserpes
discussion lifer
Posts: 340
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2006 10:37 am

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by John Tserpes »

Quality and it's adjustability to fit any person with the yoke system. The padding for your back and the shoulder straps are better. Plus a lifetime warranty. The mahal is a true backpack compared to the school book style of the grip.
Shaun LaForce
I live here
Posts: 2017
Joined: Tue Dec 05, 2006 7:55 pm
NEFA #: 865
Location: Rapscallion DGC

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Shaun LaForce »

Isaac Chaney wrote:Yea for sure! Made the 300$ worth it. It's cool knowing that the chances of running into to someone with the same bag is slim to none.



Sounds like you paid more too.
Tim Carter
I live here
Posts: 1283
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 1:41 pm

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Tim Carter »

Here are three, and please note that peeps have made each of these points earlier in the thread:

1. Inclimate weather options: including umbrella holder (for both open and closed positions) and built in, overlapping cover.

2. Flexibility / versatility: The Mahal can hold 40+ discs, or 20 discs and rain gear, snacks, etc.. or just a few disc and slims down nicely by compressing the side pockets. You don't have to fill it up, obviously.

3. proprietary., adjustable/ custom fit yoke system: making a great fit for each individual. And this goes to the " i tried a Mahal and didn't like it" comment... Did you go through the yoke adjustment process ( which u only need to do once), to actually fit the bag to your back before making this judgment? World of difference.

Also, I don't remember anyone saying the Mahal was better until you said that grip was better. At that point, I felt the need to respond. Cause you are wrong.
TEAM BUFF

STAY CLASSY
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

I'm 6'4 and the bag fits me just fine. And iv tryed on the Mahal and walked around with it as well, the comfort level on the grip outweighs the Mahal by a mile.And I have a life time warranty who said we dont?? Let's not forget shaun the bag only costs 200$. Were talking about the convenience to a majority of people, not people like me who got a special edition.
Team uncensored
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

Hah!! Tim Did you not post in our grip forum acting like a snoody azz Mahal owner, any smart person could figure out what your were implying .
Team uncensored
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

Just got off the phone with mystery ranch, they have only sold about 150 bags give or take. NUFF said.
Team uncensored
Isaac Chaney
discussion lifer
Posts: 859
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:02 pm
Nickname: standing tall

Re: choosing a backpack-style bag

Post by Isaac Chaney »

we could argue about this all day, but in the end, how well the bag is selling says it all.
Team uncensored
Post Reply